Disappointing results, declining service or concerns about transparency can quickly lead to one question: should we pitch our media agency?
The answer depends on what is causing the problems and whether the required changes can be secured within the existing relationship.
Some issues can be resolved through better processes, clearer expectations or renegotiation. Others require the competitive leverage of a media agency pitch. A different agency may be needed, but that should follow from the evidence.
This is why PREPARE matters. A thorough diagnostic assessment establishes what is happening, why it is happening and the best course of action.
Here are six principles for making that decision.
Advertisers can usually describe what is frustrating them about their media agency. Common concerns include:
These concerns establish where to investigate. They do not, by themselves, explain the cause.
Slow turnaround, for example, could reflect an understaffed agency team. It could also result from unclear briefs, repeated changes of direction or too many client approval stages. Appointing a new agency will not remove an approval bottleneck within the advertiser’s organisation.
If similar problems have followed several agency changes, examine your processes and operating model alongside agency delivery.
The lesson: Define the problem clearly before deciding that a pitch will solve it.
2. Use PREPARE to Establish the Underlying Causes
At Abintus, we combine quantitative and qualitative analysis to understand the relationship as a whole.
We examine media performance, buying prices and quality, agency remuneration, resources and delivery against agreed commitments. Relevant evidence includes campaign results, commercial benchmarks, staffing records, invoices and performance reports.
This helps establish where delivery falls short, how material the gaps are and whether the advertiser is receiving the value it has agreed to pay for.
Interviews, meetings and workshops with both advertiser and agency teams help explain the findings. We explore briefing, planning, approvals, communication, expectations and the way decisions are made.
Listening to both sides matters. The advertiser may describe an unresponsive agency, while the agency describes contradictory instructions from different stakeholders. We compare those accounts with the documents and delivery evidence to establish what needs to change.
For international advertisers, this should include relevant global, regional and local perspectives. A local execution problem may require a different response from a weakness across the agency network.
In our work, we have encountered relationships where the marketing team values the agency highly and receives responsive service, while the underlying commercial arrangements raise concerns.
The assessment may identify unfulfilled contractual commitments, uncompetitive pricing or proprietary media being used without the client’s knowledge or outside the agreed terms. Strong satisfaction scores cannot establish whether those obligations are being met.
The scope can range from a focused needs assessment to a full Holistic Media Audit. In either case, it must be thorough enough to explain the causes and support a clear recommendation.
The lesson: Assess performance, commercial delivery and the experience of both teams together.
Once the causes are understood, the next question is whether the existing partnership can deliver the necessary improvements.
Some changes are relatively straightforward: clearer briefs, fewer approval stages, better invoicing, defined responsibilities or a more effective escalation process. Others may require changes to staffing, scope, remuneration or contractual terms.
How each party responds to the findings is revealing. An agency that acknowledges a problem and commits to corrective action provides a basis for improvement. Denying established facts or repeatedly avoiding agreed action makes that prospect less credible. The advertiser must be equally willing to address its own contribution.
Willingness must be supported by capability. The incumbent needs the people, expertise and resources to meet the advertiser’s current and future requirements.
Where improvement is realistic, agree:
Keeping the agency should mean implementing an agreed improvement plan. It should not mean accepting the same unresolved issues for another year.
The lesson: Resolve the issues without a pitch when the required changes can be secured on credible, measurable terms.
An agency may be capable of making the changes an advertiser needs without being prepared to agree to them under the existing arrangement.
Material improvements to media pricing, stronger transparency provisions, different remuneration, greater senior involvement or a redesigned operating model may prove difficult to secure through direct negotiations alone.
A competitive pitch gives the advertiser credible alternatives. It allows the business to compare what other agencies can deliver and negotiate with a clearer understanding of the available options.
The relationship may be repairable, but a pitch may still be the most effective way to secure the changes required.
Competition can also reveal a gap between what an incumbent has been delivering and what it is now prepared to offer. When an agency proposes substantially better terms during a pitch, the advertiser will reasonably ask why those terms were not available earlier.
That explanation deserves scrutiny, alongside a comparison of scope, quality and commercial assumptions. The decision must consider whether the proposed improvement is credible and whether trust can be maintained.
The expected benefits should also justify the management time, cost and disruption of a review. Continuing with an unsuitable arrangement carries costs of its own.
The lesson: A pitch may be necessary to secure substantial changes, even when the incumbent could remain the right partner.
Running a media agency pitch does not automatically mean replacing the incumbent.
The outcome can be the same agency with a stronger team, improved terms, clearer commitments and more effective ways of working. Where the incumbent remains a credible candidate, it should have a genuine opportunity to retain the account if it can meet the advertiser’s requirements.
A new agency becomes more compelling where essential capabilities are missing, sustained failures remain unresolved or trust has been damaged beyond repair. Those requirements should be explicit in the pitch brief and evaluation.
A pitch may also arise from new leadership, a desire to test competitiveness or an organisation’s sourcing requirements, even when the relationship is working well. PREPARE then helps establish what the process should test and what a successful outcome would look like.
The lesson: Decide whether competition is needed first, then assess which agency can best deliver the required outcome.
Whether the incumbent stays or a new agency is appointed, the agreed changes need to be implemented and checked.
Poor onboarding and unclear expectations can create the problems that later trigger another review. Following a global or regional pitch, commitments agreed centrally must reach the local agency and advertiser teams responsible for delivering them.
Early reviews should establish whether staffing, reporting, responsibilities and ways of working are operating as agreed. Ongoing governance should then track media performance, commercial commitments, transparency and service quality, with action when gaps emerge.
A long agency relationship can serve an advertiser well when there is credible evidence of competitive value, suitable capabilities and effective collaboration. Confidence should come from that evidence and ongoing accountability, with any sourcing requirements also respected.
The lesson: Govern the chosen outcome so improvements become part of everyday delivery.
Conclusion and Next Steps
A media agency pitch should follow a clear understanding of what needs to change and whether those changes can be secured without competition.
At Abintus, PREPARE combines independent analysis with an understanding of how advertiser and agency teams work together. We can then recommend a targeted improvement plan, renegotiation or a competitive pitch, and support the implementation and governance that follow.
We are a global media agency pitch consultancy with independent auditing capability, funded exclusively by advertisers. Our role is to recommend the course of action that best serves the client’s interests.
Sometimes that means running a pitch. Sometimes it means helping the existing relationship work better.
Unsure whether your media agency issues justify a pitch? Contact us or schedule a consultation with our team to discuss how an independent assessment can establish the causes and the right next step.
Additional resources related to this topic:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About the Author
It should trigger an assessment of the causes. Problems with briefing, approvals or responsibilities may be resolved within the existing relationship. A pitch becomes appropriate when the necessary improvements cannot be secured, important capabilities are missing or credible alternatives need to be tested.
It should combine quantitative analysis of performance, costs, resources and commitments with qualitative investigation of processes, expectations and working relationships. Interviews should include both advertiser and agency stakeholders, with the scope tailored to the issues and decision.
Yes. Strong personal relationships can coexist with weak commercial delivery or unmet requirements. A pitch may provide the competitive leverage needed for substantial improvements, or it may be required under the advertiser’s sourcing policy.
No. The incumbent may retain the business if its proposal best meets the agreed requirements. The outcome can be a materially improved relationship with the same agency, supported by a revised team, operating model, contract and measurable commitments.
Agree the improvements, responsibilities, resources and review date. Track implementation and performance through ongoing governance. If the changes fail to materialise or the evidence no longer supports retaining the agency, reconsider the decision.